Friday, October 14, 2016

Peer-to-peer lending platform Mintos independent review

Mintos Background

Mintos is one of the fastest growing peer-to-peer lending platforms in Continental Europe. They have gained massive momentum by providing investors a platform that allows buying loan claims issued by payday lenders in Eastern Europe. The acquired claims are backed by buyback guarantees.

Buyback guarantee is an insurance product where the platform buys back the claim at nominal value (plus accrued interest) if the underlying loan defaults. In return investors are buying loan claim at a very low interest rate compared to the risk. There are loans available without buyback guarantees but investors have so far primarily acquired loans with these guarantees.

I unfortunately recently discovered that the reasons why I thought Mintos is the best platform in the industry are all lies.

Mintos is bankrupt

Mintos states that “Buy-back guarantee is a guarantee issued by the loan originator to the investor for a particular loan, whereas the loan originator will repurchase the loan from the investor if that particular loan becomes delayed more than 60 days”. In reality investors do not have any claims against the loan originators but against Mintos. When troubles come then investors are left with nothing as Mintos’ balance sheet is nearly 30 times smaller than the outstanding size of the buyback guarantees.

Mintos needs to properly account for buyback guarantees by classifying buyback guarantees as liabilities. Mintos management should thereafter file for bankruptcy protection as they do not have enough assets or reserves to cover the liabilities. This issue should be raised with the regulators and their auditor immediately before Mintos blows up with over 30 million euro of investor money.

Read below to understand why Mintos, not the loan originators, are liable for buyback guarantees.

Mintos is channeling investors’ money to its owner

Mintos states that “At the Mintos marketplace, you will find plenty of loans to invest in. Diversify across loan types, loan originators, and different geographies”. In reality over 80% of the capital is being used to fund the operations of Mintos’ actual founder and CEO Aigars Kesenfelds, the son of a Latvian politician and businessman Ivars Kesenfelds  who financed Aigars’ payday lending businesses initially. Mintos, Mogo, Hipocredit, Lendo and Banknote are all controlled by Aigars Kesenfelds. See below for documents proving the associations.

The outstanding balances of the originators on Mintos make up 80.23% of the outstanding portfolio. The rest of the businesses could have links to Mintos but I was only able to verify ownership details of companies where ultimate owners were registered in Latvia and that had meaningful size.



Capitalia at first seems independent however one of their board members Mārtiņš Krūtainis is also on the board of Hipocredit.

The ownership structure of Creamfinance (6.97% of the outstanding portfolio) lead to Cyprus - a country preferred by Russian capital.

Kredito Garantas, Creditstar, Aforti, Debifo, Acema, Aventus, Mano Unija and Agrocredit are all potentially independent. However they collectively make up only 3.91% of the total portfolio and act only as marketing gimmicks to push the diversification statement.

Scroll below for the supporting documents and more detailed explanation of the ownership structure.

Why is Mintos liable for buyback guarantees?

Mintos is liable for the buyback guarantees instead of the loan originators as the liability for honoring the buyback guarantee has been assigned to Mintos from the loan originator. Subsection 4 of paragraph 5.1.1. of the Assignment Agreement states that:

Mintos, as the representative of the Loan Originator, shall act on behalf of the Loan Originator pursuant the cooperation agreement concluded by and between the Loan Originator and Mintos by carrying out the following activities: 4) in case the buyback right of the Loan Originator is exercised, pay the buyback price of the Claim to the Assignee.

The assignment agreement further goes to state that buyback guarantee is a right of the loan originator, not its obligation. Only in case the collateral is sold or borrower is declared insolvent by court (which never happens with personal loans), does the loan originator have the liability to exercise the buyback right. However it still needs to be honored by Mintos.

11.2. The Loan Originator has the right, but not an obligation to use its buyback rights in any of the following events:
11.2.1. the Borrowers delays the payments arising from the Loan Agreement by more than 60 (sixty) days;
11.2.2. the Assignee has fully or partially recalled the authorization included in the Agreement or the Terms and Conditions of the Portal User;
11.2.3. Mintos pursuant to the Terms and Conditions of the Portal User has limited the Assignee’s rights to use the Portal;
11.2.4. in event of early termination of the Agreement;
11.2.5. pursuant to unilateral decision of the Loan Originator.
11.7. In addition to the provisions specified in Clause 11.2 of the General Terms and Conditions, if the sale of the Collateral or insolvency proceedings of the Borrower are commenced, the Loan Originator immediately exercises buyback rights granted to it by Mintos giving written notice thereof to the Assignee at its email address. Buyback rights specified in this Clause are exercised by the Loan Originator in the interests of the Assignee to ensure that the proceeds obtained from the sale of the Collateral are used to cover the Claim owned by the Assignee. As of the date of notice by Mintos to the Assignee, the Claim is considered sold back and transferred to the Loan Originator.

Why is this dangerous for investors?

Mintos states that “Every loan on the Mintos marketplace is pre-funded by the respective loan originator, which, moreover, will keep a certain percentage of the loan on its balance sheet. As the result, the incentives of loan originators and investors are aligned.” In reality Aigars Kesenfelds has designed a structure whereby funds from individual investors are directed to his companies at very low interest rates compared to the risks the companies are taking with all risks staying with the investor.

1) In case the loan performs then the loan originator is making up to 138% return on the loans (https://lendo.ge/ is issuing loans at 150% interest rates and passing only 12% to investors).
2) In addition they are making up to 7.5% of the loan amount on issuing the loan by service fees (In Latvia: https://www.mogo.lv/lv/kalkulators/ - Līguma noformēšanas komisija 7,5% no aizdevuma summas, bet ne mazāk kā 150 EUR; 7,5% no līzinga summas, bet ne mazāk kā 150 EUR)
3) In case the loan does not perform there is no liability for the loan originator as they have assigned the principal claim, plus a small share of the interest, to the investors on Mintos.
4) In case they have sold the loan with a buyback guarantee then they do not have to honor it as by law this liability has been passed to Mintos, a shell company with no meaningful assets and equity.
5) The companies are supposedly keeping a small 10% neck-in-the-game share of the loan to align risks. However point 1 and 2 above shows that this is only cosmetic and in practice they do not have to put any capital aside or get this capital back already in a month or so.

In other words – Aigars is able to earn spreads of 100%+ on loan portfolios where he has not committed any capital himself and where risks are all pushed to individual investors whilst returns all kept to himself.

How are Mintos and loan originators connected?

My research is based on public company registry information available in Latvia as well as basic online searched in LinkedIn and Google. I have enclosed the original documents as well as simplified overviews created based on this information.

List in Excel: https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B2xTRapiRmJzUlVOQ1ZvZU5hc2c
Relationship Map 1: https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B2xTRapiRmJzRnZYM01GRXpIYWs
Relationship Map 2: https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B2xTRapiRmJzRmJMeFlWeUpEajQ

Many of the people shared between companies are actually employees of FORT Law who probably is offering nominee services for Aigars to be able to cover up true ownership. You will find that 6 companies have board/council members who actually work here: http://fortlegal.com/people/




AS Mintos Holdings is a shareholder for AS Mintos Marketplace. AS Skillion Ventures is a shareholder for AS Mintos Holdings. AS Skillion Ventures is in turn is owned by Aigars Kesenfelds. AS Skillion Ventures is also the owner of AS Hipocredit. Skillion/Aigars Kesenfelds is also the owner of the Mogo and SIA "ExpressCredit" (Banknote). Lendo is owned by SIA "EC Investments" which in turn is owned by SIA "ExpressCredit"

News story on Aigars launching Skillion Ventures: http://www.db.lv/tehnologijas/kesenfelds-juniors-sak-jaunu-biznesa-projektu-238647
Mintos Holdings registry extract: https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B2xTRapiRmJzQXRWcDR0TUxXa2M
Mintos Marketplace registry extract: https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B2xTRapiRmJzT2VMZkNNRjAxWUU

HIPOCREDIT - Joint Stock Company "Hipocredit". The Board and the Council are the same as for MINTOS (AS Mintos Holdings and AS Mintos Marketplace), AS Skillion Ventures and AS Mogo.

Hipocredit registry extract: https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B2xTRapiRmJzMFdqUzNUaGZRREU

BANKNOTE - Limited Liability Company "Express Credit". 3 Council Members, from which all are also represented in other companies like Mogo, EC Investments, Mintos and Skillion Ventures. Aigars Kesenfelds is an owner of the company, based on his LinkedIn profile. SIA AE Consulting and SIA Lombards24.lv are the Shareholders for Banknote (SIA Expresskredit) LV, and all three companies share the same Shareholders/Board members.

ExpressCredit registry extract: https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B2xTRapiRmJzT25OVmNoOThXU3M

Mogo - Joint Stock Company "Mogo". The Council consists of 5 Members, from which three members are also in other companies such as MINTOS, Banknote, EC Investments, Skillion Ventures and Hipocredit. Aigars Kesenfelds is an owner of the company, based on his LinkedIn profile. Previously AS Skillion Ventures was also publicly shown as an owner (see visual map above).



Mogo registry extract: https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B2xTRapiRmJzMmdUMkRWbDFZazA

LLC Lendo is owned by SIA “EC Investments” which is owned by SIA "ExpressCredit" (Banknote).
EC Investments, SIA – same shareholders with AS Mogo, SIA "AE Consulting", Banknote (SIA Expresskredit) LV, AS Mintos Marketplace (LV), AS Mintos Holdings (LV), AS Skillion Ventures (LV). Lendo LLC, SIA "Lombards24.lv", SIA "AE Consulting". EC Investments managers have previously been on the board of AS Skillion ventures.

Lendo registry extract: https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B2xTRapiRmJzbjl3ckZQNmRab0U

Capitalia - Joint Stock Company "Capitalia". Council has 3 members, from which the Chairman is also a member of the Council in AS Hipocredit. AS Capitalia has a pledge of Creamfinance.

Capitalia registry extract: https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B2xTRapiRmJza0gxSTZDbHh0MUU

CREAM FINANCE - Limited Liability Company "CREAM Finance". AS Capitalia has a pledge of Creamfinance

Creamfinance registry extract: https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B2xTRapiRmJzdU05RlVvdUVVWEU

What should I do?

If you think you have been misled by Mintos then contact the regulators in Latvia:


The size of this financial scheme has already grown enormous. If Mintos is stopped today then the situation might resolve without causing actual losses as Aigars and his companies potentially still have the funds to repay investors. If you wait to take action you are risking of losing all your funds.








25 comments:

  1. I am always on the lookout for quality posts and articles so i suppose im lucky to have found this! I hope you will be adding more in the future..

    Stock Finance Services Hong Kong

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. testimony of my life

      Good day everyone,my name is Jessica from USA i am here to testify about how i got a real and working blank ATM card from a good hacker on the internet, i was very poor before and i have been unemployed since 2015, i came across a post on the internet concerning the blank ATM card and i decided to give it a try,i agreed to the terms and conditions to receive the card.
      it worked like magic when i received this card and i was able to withdraw 5000$ daily with this card, i have a car of my own now and i have gotten a house too.
      if you need a real blank ATM card, contact this good hacker on his email mrfrankblankatmcard@gmail.com
      i post this here because i know you can also be favoured by this testimony.
      thanks

      Delete
  2. The list of Board members and Supervisory Board members of ACEMA Credit Czech a.s. is publicly available here (in Czech language) https://or.justice.cz/ias/ui/rejstrik-firma.vysledky?subjektId=522513&typ=PLATNY but the owners are not disclosed. From the legal document available here https://or.justice.cz/ias/ui/vypis-sl-firma?subjektId=522513 one can read that the 95% owner is a Cyprus company Davis Salomon Group LTD.

    Are you able to uncover also Twino's ownership structure?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks for your research. Lots of alarming information there.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I don't think I agree with you on the points 3 and 4 about the dangers of Mintos that Mintos is liable to pay the buyback.

    In 10.3 of the agreement it explicitly says that Mintos transfers the funds from the Loan Originator to the Investor in case of the Buyback right is exercised after 60 days. The Loan Originator has the obligation (not a right) to pay the Buyback after 60 days of payment delays (this is the agreement where there is a buyback). So why have you concluded otherwise?

    The sentence in 10.3: "The Loan Originator hereby authorizes Mintos, in case if the Loan Originator’s obligation to exercise its buyback obligations have occurred, to write off from the Loan Originator’s Account and transfer the virtual money equivalent to the buyback price to the Virtual Account of the Assignee immediately, without obtaining prior separate order from the Loan Originator."

    ReplyDelete
  5. A have a big percentage of my portfolio invested in Mintos and this article scares me. But all of the loans I made in the previous year were with the "Buyback guarantee after 60 days non payment" worked out, and paid back the money. Would something like this be allowed within the EU?

    ReplyDelete
  6. DO YOU NEED 100% FINANCE? we give out loans with an affordable interest rate of 3% (fastreliablefirm@gmail.com) aims is to provide Excellent Professional Financial Services.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hello Everybody,
    My name is Ahmad Asnul Brunei, I contacted Mr Osman Loan Firm for a business loan amount of $250,000, Then i was told about the step of approving my requested loan amount, after taking the risk again because i was so much desperate of setting up a business to my greatest surprise, the loan amount was credited to my bank account within 24 banking hours without any stress of getting my loan. I was surprise because i was first fall a victim of scam! If you are interested of securing any loan amount & you are located in any country, I'll advise you can contact Mr Osman Loan Firm via email osmanloanserves@gmail.com

    LOAN APPLICATION INFORMATION FORM
    First name......
    Middle name.....
    2) Gender:.........
    3) Loan Amount Needed:.........
    4) Loan Duration:.........
    5) Country:.........
    6) Home Address:.........
    7) Mobile Number:.........
    8) Email address..........
    9) Monthly Income:.....................
    10) Occupation:...........................
    11)Which site did you here about us.....................
    Thanks and Best Regards.
    Derek Email osmanloanserves@gmail.com



    Hello Everybody,
    My name is Ahmad Asnul Brunei, I contacted Mr Osman Loan Firm for a business loan amount of $250,000, Then i was told about the step of approving my requested loan amount, after taking the risk again because i was so much desperate of setting up a business to my greatest surprise, the loan amount was credited to my bank account within 24 banking hours without any stress of getting my loan. I was surprise because i was first fall a victim of scam! If you are interested of securing any loan amount & you are located in any country, I'll advise you can contact Mr Osman Loan Firm via email osmanloanserves@gmail.com

    LOAN APPLICATION INFORMATION FORM
    First name......
    Middle name.....
    2) Gender:.........
    3) Loan Amount Needed:.........
    4) Loan Duration:.........
    5) Country:.........
    6) Home Address:.........
    7) Mobile Number:.........
    8) Email address..........
    9) Monthly Income:.....................
    10) Occupation:...........................
    11)Which site did you here about us.....................
    Thanks and Best Regards.
    Derek Email osmanloanserves@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  8. Peer to Peer Lending is worth considering as an option as long as you have very good credit and can come up with the fixed monthly payment when business is slack. After all, peer to peer lending is geared toward consumers and not business owners.

    ReplyDelete
  9. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Private Lender Bentex Funding Group Ltd.
    Greetings to you by (BFGL).
    We are a France-Paris based investment company known as Bentex Funding
    Group Ltd working on expanding its portfolio globally and financing
    projects.

    We would be happy to fund and invest with you in any profitable
    project if you have any viable project we can finance by making mutual
    investment with you. If you are interested, kindly contact us
    on:avitinvestmentauthority2@gmail.com for more details.
    Looking forward hearing from you soonest.
    Yours truly,
    Mrs Rose Larsson.
    (Personal Assistant)
    Bentex Funding Group Ltd(BFGL)
    509 Rue Jacques Coeur,75008 Paris-France
    Paris-France.Bentex Funding Group Ltd (BFGL)

    ReplyDelete


  11. A lot of us are still unaware of the recent development of the Blank ATM card.. An ATM card that can change your financial status within few days. With this Blank ATM card, you can withdraw between €1000-€10,000 daily from any ATM machine in the world. There is no risk of getting caught by any form of security if you followed the instructions properly. The Blank ATM card is also sophisticated due to the fact that the card has its own security making your transaction very safe and untraceable. For more info contact us with the below address and you can also watch our YouTube to read customers review.E-mail: blankatm002@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  12. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Invest with 200$ and get a returns of 5,000$ within seven business working days.
    Why wasting your precious time online looking for a loan? When there is an opportunity for you to invest with 200$ and get a returns of 5,000$ within seven business working days. Contact us now for more information if interested on how you can earn big with just little amount. This is all about investing into Crude Oil and Gas Business.

    Email: investmoneyoilgas@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  14. Hello semua,
    Nama saya Puan Cynthia Corvin. Saya tinggal di Amerika Syarikat dan saya seorang wanita gembira hari ini? dan saya memberitahu diri saya bahawa mana-mana pemberi pinjaman yang menyelamatkan keluargaku dari situasi kita yang buruk, saya akan merujuk sesiapa sahaja yang mencari pinjaman kepadanya, dia memberi saya kebahagiaan kepada saya dan keluarga saya, saya memerlukan pinjaman sebanyak S $ 250,000.00 untuk memulakan hidup saya seluruh sebagai saya seorang ibu tunggal dengan 2 anak-anak saya bertemu dengan jujur ​​ini dan ALLAH takut kepada pemberi pinjaman pinjaman lelaki yang membantu saya dengan pinjaman $ 250,000.00. Dolar, dia adalah seorang yang takut kepada manusia, jika anda memerlukan pinjaman dan anda akan membayar balik pinjaman, sila hubungi dia memberitahunya bahawa Puan Cynthia yang merujuk anda kepadanya. hubungi En.Isa Mohammed, asialoanfirms2020@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  15. Get Your Urgent Blank Atm Card Now To Pay Your Debt And Start A Good Life Contact Email Via:harrylee62@live.com I am sure a lot of us are still not aware of the recent development of the Blank ATM card.. An ATM card that can change your financial status within few days. With this Blank ATM card, you can withdraw between $2,000-$3,000 -$5,500-$8,800-$12,000-$20,000-$35,000 -$50,000 and $100,000 daily from any ATM machine in the world. There is no risk of getting caught by any form of security if you followed the instructions properly. The Blank ATM card is also sophisticated due to the fact that the card has its own security making your transaction very safe and untraceable. i am not a stupid man that i will come out to the public and start saying what someone have not done. For more info contact Mr Harry and also on how you are going to get your Card, Order yours today via Email: harrylee62@live.com

    whatsapp: +13122989500


    web site..https://harrylee62.wordpress.com/2020/01/08/blank-atm-card/

    ReplyDelete

  16. Stop wasting your time looking for a loan. Invest with just $ 100 and get a yield of $ 2,500 in four business days. It is a way to help those in need and also use small amount to get financial approval problems. And it is the best offer you can get. Contact us today for more details if you are interested in knowing more about this great offer on how your $ 100 can get a return of $ 2,500 in four business days. Contact us by email: Sharemaxinvestment12@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete


  17. INSTEAD OF GETTING A LOAN,, I GOT SOMETHING NEW
    Get $5000 USD every day, for six months!

    See how it works
    Do you know you can hack into any ATM machine with a hacked ATM card??
    Make up you mind before applying, straight deal...

    Order for a blank ATM card now and get millions within a week!: contact us
    via email address::{int.hackers002@gmail.com}
    Do you know that you can hack any ATM machine !!!

    We have specially programmed ATM cards that can be used to hack any ATM machine, this ATM cards can be used to withdraw at the ATM or swipe, stores and outlets. We sell this cards to all our customers and interested buyers worldwide, the cards has a daily withdrawal limit of $5000 in ATM and up to $50,000 spending limit in stores. and also if you in need of any other cyber hacking services, we are here for you at any time any day. contact us via
    email address:: {int.hackers002@gmail.com}

    ReplyDelete
  18. Hi everyone, i am so glade coming back to this great forum to testify about the help i received from Carrol Walker. I was in desperate need of a loan in other to be free from debt and financial bondage that was place on me by my ex husband. It was really bad that i have to seek for help from Friends,family and even my bank but on one could assist me because my credit score was really bad. So i was browsing with my computer and saw some testimonies from people Carrol Walker assisted with a loan, then i decided to contact him on his email{infoloanfirm8@gmail.com}, then i received a mail from them and i did all that was asked from me. To my greatest surprise they transferred to my account the loan i requested and now i am so happy clearing my debt and have also started a business with the remaining amount to take care of myself and family. If you need a loan do contact the best loan lender of all time Carrol Walker on his email: {infoloanfirm8@gmail.com}

    ReplyDelete
  19. What are your Financial needs? We give out loans from a minimum of $5,000 to a maximum of $100,000,000.00 with comfortable duration that ranges from 1 to 35 years at a very reduced interest rate of 3%. Contact us via email: {infoloanfirm8@gmail.com}
    Thanks and look forward to your prompt reply.
    Regards,
    Carrol Walker

    ReplyDelete
  20. Attention:
    Are you looking for a REAL FINANCIAL LOAN COMPANY  to give you loan between 5,000 Euro and 50,000,000 Euro (for a business or company loan, personal loan, home loans, car loan, debt consolidation loans, venture capital, healthcare loan, etc.) Or have you been denied a loan from a bank or financial institution because of one reason or the other? Apply now and get real financial loan processed and approved within 3 days. CHRIST DIAMOND LOAN FIRM, we are an "Internationally Accredited Loan Lender" that give REAL FINANCIAL LOANS to individuals and companies in a low interest rate of 2% with your valid identity card or your country international passport for verification. Our loan Repayment starts 1 (One) year after you have received your loan, and repayment duration ranges from between 3 to 35 years duration.FOR IMMEDIATE RESPONSE AND PROCESSING OF YOUR LOAN REQUEST WITHIN 2 WORKING DAYS,

    Contact us directly through this email: christdiamondloanfirm@gmail.com

    Contact us with the following information:

    Full Name:____________________________
    Amount Needed as Loan:________________
    Loan Duration:_________________________
    Purpose for __________________________
    Loan:______________________
    Date of Birth:___________________________
    Gender:_______________________________
    Marital status:__________________________
    Contact __________________________
    Address:_______________________
    City/Zip code:__________________________
    Country:_______________________________
    Occupation:____________________________
    Mobile __________________________
    Phone:__________________________

    Send your request for immediate response to: christdiamondloanfirm@gmail.com

    Thank you.
    CHRIST DIAMOND
    Director.
    CHRIST DIAMOND LOAN FIRM
    Email:christdiamondloanfirm@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  21. Do you need Finance?
    Are you looking for Finance?
    Are you looking for a money to enlarge your business?
    We help individuals and companies to obtain loan for business
    expanding and to setup a new business ranging any amount. Get a loan at affordable interest rate of 3%, Do you need this cash/loan for business and to clear your bills? Then send us an email now for more information contact us now via Email: inforamzanloan@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  22. Need a Debt Loan To Pay Off Bills?
    Take control of your debt today
    Available Now Business Expansion Loan Offer?
    Do you need a loan to pay off Bills?
    Do you need a loan?
    Do you need Personal Loan?
    Business Expansion Loan?
    Business Start-up, Education,
    Debt Consolidation Loan
    Hard Money Loans
    Loan for any thing ?
    We offer loan at low interest rate of 3%
    Loan with no credit check,
    Email us: infoloanfirm8@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete